An editorial daily for the Heart of the Commonwealth.

History

Worcester's sewer charges are one reason three-deckers sit sideways on narrow lots

The three-story wood house was built by the tens of thousands for factory workers, and Worcester is the likely place it began.

Published

A Worcester builder after 1870 had a good reason to want a skinny lot. The city set its sewer connection charge by how much of the lot faced the street, so less frontage meant a smaller bill. Builders chose narrow lots and turned the house sideways, short end to the street.

That rule is one reason the three-decker looks the way it does. Between 1870 and 1920, the house spread through the growing industrial cities of central New England.

A house built for the factory floor

A three-decker is a detached three-story building, usually of light wood framing, with one apartment on each floor. Tens of thousands went up in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, mostly in New England. Newly arrived immigrant workers were filling the region's factories, and the house was a cheap way to put a roof over them.

Other Northeastern cities, among them New York City, Boston, Philadelphia, Baltimore and Washington, D.C., built narrow single-unit row houses in those years. The three-decker was seen as the alternative.

Worcester is the likely origin of the type, though other cities make the same claim. Massachusetts and Rhode Island have the largest concentrations. Hipped and gabled roofs dominate in Worcester.

Inside and out

Windows sat on all four sides, with a bay window facing the street on each floor. The utility porch was at the rear, out of sight from the street. Some houses had one front door for all three apartments. Others had a separate entrance for the bottom floor and another that led to the top two. Victorian ornament was mostly missing, though some builders added porch railings and posts.

Extended families often lived on two floors or all three. Some buildings were divided into six units.

Boston is the example with a count: an estimate puts its three-deckers at over 15,000 by 1920. Dorchester, Roxbury, Mattapan and Jamaica Plain became "streetcar suburbs" as transit lines grew out from the older core of the city. The affordable houses tended to attract live-in landlords, who collected rent from the other two apartments.

A bad name

Critics called the buildings shoddy. A 1911 report by the Massachusetts State Housing Committee attacked them as fire hazards. In 1912 Massachusetts passed the Tenement Act, which let municipalities ban three-deckers. Many did.

The concern was the construction. The houses are wood, typically built with balloon framing, which makes fires especially destructive. Old knob-and-tube wiring, antiquated gas appliances and petroleum-based shingle siding add to it. GBH News reported that fire officials in Worcester, Fall River, Brockton and New Bedford all said these buildings made up a disproportionate share of their structure fire calls.

Out of favor, then back

By the 1950s, a number of three-deckers had been abandoned or torn down, mainly because of zoning, suburban growth and urban renewal. Their reputation for low quality lasted into the 1970s.

In the early 1980s, buyers returned as older streetcar suburbs began to gentrify. Many wanted to live in one apartment and collect rent on the other two to help cover the mortgage. As condominiums became more common, many three-deckers were converted into individually owned units.

Starting in 1990, many of Worcester's three-deckers were added to the National Register of Historic Places.

In 2019, Somerville made the structures legal again, and in 2023 it removed many restrictions to comply with the MBTA Communities Act.